Expert insight
The property ladder isn’t always climbed upwards.
The phrase “property ladder” carries a fairly clear expectation.
You buy your first flat, move to a small house, buy a bigger one as your family grows and eventually reach the home you’ve been working towards. Each move takes you another rung up the ladder.
It’s a familiar picture. But after more than twenty years advising people about their mortgages, I think it describes only part of the story.
People move sideways. They buy smaller homes. They start again, combine households, move abroad or decide that the house they once aspired to no longer suits the life they want.
A property journey can change direction several times. And the direction of the move tells you surprisingly little about whether it is a good one.
Bigger makes sense for a while
There are stages of life when more space makes a considerable difference.
Children arrive. Bedrooms need separating. Working from home makes the kitchen table less practical. A garden becomes somewhere to spend time rather than something to maintain.
Moving to a larger property can be a sensible response to those changes. Taking on more borrowing may also feel comfortable where earnings have grown and there is sufficient room in the household budget.
But the assumption that the next home should always be bigger can outlast the reasons for needing it.
An extra bedroom has a cost, even when nobody sleeps in it. A larger mortgage also makes demands on income that might eventually be wanted for something else.
The important question is what the additional space will do for the people living there.
A sideways move can change everything
Some of the most worthwhile moves involve very little change in property value.
Someone might exchange a larger house with a long commute for a smaller home within walking distance of work. A family might move to be closer to grandparents. Another household might trade spare bedrooms for a more suitable layout, a different neighbourhood or easier access to schools.
On paper, they may appear to have stayed on the same rung.
Their daily lives could be considerably better.
Location, convenience, support and time are difficult to capture in a property valuation, but they often explain why someone wants to move far better than the number of bedrooms.
Understanding those priorities is an important part of the mortgage conversation. Otherwise, it is very easy to spend the whole discussion establishing what someone can afford without understanding what they actually want to achieve.
A smaller home can create more choices
Downsizing is often spoken about as something people do towards the end of their property journey.
In practice, the decision can make sense much earlier.
Someone may want to reduce their working hours, establish a business, help their children or simply have less of their income committed each month. Others have reached a point where maintaining the house and garden takes more time than they want to give it.
Moving to a less expensive property may help release equity or reduce borrowing, although the costs of moving need to be included in that calculation.
The benefit might be greater financial flexibility. It might be a home that is easier to manage. It might be the ability to make a career decision that previously felt out of reach.
Calling that a move “down” the ladder seems a rather limited way of describing it.
Some changes are not planned
Of course, people do not always change direction by choice.
Separation, bereavement, ill health or a reduction in income can mean reconsidering a home that once felt permanent.
These conversations require care. A property can hold years of family history, and a decision that looks straightforward in a spreadsheet may feel very different to the person making it.
Sometimes the priority is to remain in the home. Sometimes it is to establish whether one person can take over the mortgage. Sometimes moving provides a more manageable starting point.
The role of an adviser is to understand what matters, explain what is realistically possible and help the client make an informed decision.
There is no useful place in that conversation for assumptions about where someone ought to be on a property ladder.
The mortgage has to reflect life today
One complication is that a change in property does not always produce the mortgage outcome someone expects.
A person buying a cheaper home may still need a fresh assessment of their income and circumstances. They might now be self-employed, working fewer hours or approaching retirement. Following a separation, borrowing previously supported by two incomes may need to be assessed on one.
Even where a mortgage product is portable, transferring it to another property is subject to the lender’s requirements and approval.
Having comfortably paid a larger mortgage for years does not, by itself, guarantee approval for a smaller one.
That can feel counterintuitive. It is also a good reason to explore the borrowing position early, while there is time to understand the options and plan the move properly.
Staying put is part of the journey too
A change of direction does not always involve a new address.
Extending, adapting the layout or making a home more accessible may allow it to serve a different stage of life. Reviewing the mortgage may also help someone reconsider their borrowing, repayment plans and future commitments.
The house can stay the same while the role it plays changes considerably.
A home bought for a growing family might later accommodate an ageing parent, adult children returning home or a different pattern of work.
There is no requirement to keep moving simply because the language of the property ladder suggests we should.
Progress means different things at different times
Early in life, progress might mean having a front door of your own. Later, it might mean more space, a shorter commute, lower monthly commitments or being closer to the people who matter.
Those priorities can change more than once.
For me, good mortgage advice starts with understanding where someone is now and what they want their next stage of life to look like.
Sometimes that leads to a bigger house and a larger mortgage. Sometimes it leads to a smaller home, less borrowing or staying exactly where they are.
The property ladder is a useful expression. But a successful property journey is measured by how well your home and mortgage fit your life at each stage.
Dan Gracie
Director, Mortgage Adviser
Frequently asked questions.
Every client and every mortgage is different, but there are some questions we are asked regularly.
From affordability and deposits to complex income, expat mortgages and specialist property finance, our FAQs explain how different lenders may approach different circumstances.
Find out more….
See how we’ve helped….
Start a conversation….
…. or call us on 0207 126 8200.
…. or call us on 0207 126 8200.
Find out more….
See how we’ve helped….